In our next deep dive into the top five student challenges, we examine the persistent issue of mental health. With most students reporting struggles, we share their voices and offer concrete strategies for instructors to create a more supportive learning environment.
The Link to Exhaustion
In an earlier post, we explored systemic exhaustion reported by 77% of our students: a fatigue born from relentless schedules and competing demands. The state of chronic depletion is rarely an isolated challenge. It is intricately linked to the topic of this post: student mental health. When energy is perpetually low, resilience erodes, and the emotional and cognitive load of being a student becomes overwhelming. Today, we examine the data and stories behind the second most consistent challenge in our survey: mental health.
How Widespread Are Mental Health Challenges?
Our surveys provide a clear answer: mental health is a pervasive and central concern in the student experience. By combining Fall 2024 and Spring 2025 surveys (with 1,841 and 1,905 respondents, respectively), we see that an average of nearly three-quarters (72.5%) of students navigated some level of mental health challenge.
Digging deeper into the semesterly trend reveals a nuanced pattern. While student exhaustion typically increased in the spring, self-reported mental health challenges showed a modest but notable decrease, dipping from 74% in the fall to 71% in the spring. The divergence is critical; it suggests that factors beyond pure workload (i.e., course structure, timing of support, student acclimation) play a significant role in well-being.
Ultimately, this data confirms that supporting student mental health is not a peripheral issue but a fundamental aspect of creating an effective learning environment.
What Do Learners Say About Their Mental Health?
The narratives move us beyond statistics to human experiences, highlighting that mental health is not separate from learning; it is a filter through which learning happens.
The numbers only tell part of the story. The qualitative data, the students’ voices, reveal how mental health struggles permeate their academic lives. Our analysis of their comments revealed three distinct themes:
Theme 1: Compounding Pressure
“My coursework makes my existing struggles worse.”
Students don’t arrive as blank slates; they bring complex mental health histories into an inherently stressful environment. The academic workload, high-stakes grading, and rigid schedules don’t just cause stress—they actively worsen diagnosed conditions like anxiety, depression, and PTSD.
This is the first theme that emerged: how students felt pressure.
“School has induced stress and anxiety I have never had before.”
“I’ve been medicated for a few years for my anxiety and depression and since college it may have gotten worse… the constant never ending flow of work that is impossible all to complete.”
Theme 2: Isolation and Loneliness
“I feel profoundly alone in this.”
Beyond academics, a profound sense of isolation permeates the student experience. This stems from being an older/non-traditional student, living situations (with difficult roommates or off-campus), a lack of community, and the struggle to form meaningful connections in a transitory environment.
“I don’t talk much to people and it doesn’t help that everybody seems to already have a friend or two in class…”
“I live off campus with two roommates who don’t really want me [there]. That is not the best situation… feeling alone is the main issue for me.”
Theme 3: A Plea for Compassion
“We need systems, not just slogans.”
“There is a big push for self-care and mental health awareness… but many mental health issues among graduate students stem from systemic inequalities and lack of resources.”
“I feel there is little to no lenience for students who are struggling, and it is easy to get left behind if you begin struggling.”
How We Can Help
While instructors are not mental health professionals, the learning environment we create can either exacerbate or alleviate student distress. Here are tangible ways to design courses that support mental well-being.
- Normalize and Signpost Resources Proactively
Destigmatize help-seeking by treating mental health resources as integral to academic success, like the library or writing center.
Include a “Wellbeing and Support” section in your syllabus and Canvas course. List the University Counseling Center, Crisis Text Line, and basic needs resources (like the Cardinal Kitchen) all under one heading. No need to reinvent the wheel: these resources can be accessed in one Canvas page by downloading our Welcome Module from Canvas Commons.
- Design for Predictability and Control
Use a consistent course structure (e.g., modules that open on the same day each week) to reduce cognitive load and uncertainty. Implement a “No Questions Asked” late policy for 1-2 assignments, adopt a Canvas Late Pass, or use a simple dropped-grade scheme. Download a Canvas template with a consistent course structure.
- Incorporate Micro-Connections and Reduce Anonymity
Small gestures of recognition like low-stake check-ins combat isolation and help you spot when a student is disengaging due to distress. It builds the relational trust needed for a student to send an email saying, “I’m struggling.”
Use low-stakes, non-academic check-ins (e.g., start-of-the-week polls, one-word-to-describe-your-week word clouds, start class by asking students how they are). Learn and use your students’ names.
- Reframe Communication Around Care
Use supportive, non-judgmental language in emails and announcements. This models compassion and shifts the dynamic from punitive to supportive. It aligns with the “acknowledge life outside of the classroom” principle from our student challenges blog post, directly addressing the systemic issues students named.
Final Thoughts
Addressing student mental health requires a systemic shift, but pedagogical choices can create pockets of safety and resilience in our classrooms. By normalizing conversations, designing with flexibility, and connecting students with resources, we can help carry the load.
How does your course design currently account for student well-being? Could a small change in your syllabus or weekly routine make a significant difference?
References
Ambrose, Susan A., Michael W. Bridges, Michele DiPietro, Marsha C. Lovett, and Marie K. Norman. 2010. How Learning Works: Seven Research-Based Principles for Smart Teaching. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Carello, Janice, and Lisa D. Butler. “Practicing what we teach: Trauma-informed educational practice.” Journal of Teaching in Social Work 35, no. 3 (2015): 262-278.
Lattie, Emily G., Sarah Ketchen Lipson, and Daniel Eisenberg. 2019. “Technology and College Student Mental Health: Challenges and Opportunities.” Frontiers in Psychiatry 10: 246.
Walter, Melissa C., and Tammy S. Wynard. “Preparing educators to support SEL: The foundational role of trauma-informed training.” Social and Emotional Learning: Research, Practice, and Policy 5 (2025): 100071.

Comments: